Editor’s Choice Value Hotels

It isn’t entirely true that you get what you pay for. From a city centre stay to cheap countryside B&Bs, these are the places where you really get your money’s worth. Manor houses with spacious bedrooms, morning greetings from resident chickens or cleverly designed compact rooms in the city.  Here are the Good Hotel Guide’s Editor’s Choice selections for best value for money hotels.

2019 Editor's Choice Value Hotels

Editor’s Choice Value Hotels

1
Aynsome Manor

Aynsome Manor

Cartmel

Warm hospitality, centuries-old architecture and ‘beautiful countryside’ again delighted loyal fans of this ‘exceptionally good-value oasis of peace and tranquillity.’
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • wi-fi
25% voucher
2
The Ceilidh Place

The Ceilidh Place

Ullapool

There’s ‘a good night’s sleep’ and more at Jean Urquhart’s ‘lively’ Ceilidh Place – a popular fusion of cultural hub, bookshop and small hotel, one street back from the ferry terminal.
  • weddings
  • child_friendly
  • garden
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • value
  • wi-fi
25% voucher
3
Brooks Country House

Brooks Country House

Ross-on-wye

Overlooking National Trust parkland, this Georgian country house has ‘a real sense of grandeur’, say inspectors in 2018.
  • bird_watching
  • walking
  • outdoor_pool
  • parking
  • wi-fi
  • child_friendly
  • dog_friendly
  • garden
  • country_house
  • weddings
  • gym
10% discount voucher Upgrade voucher
4
The Black Swan

The Black Swan

Ravenstonedale

A babbling brook etches a course past Louise Dinnes’s ‘good-value, thoroughly dependable’ Victorian pub-with-rooms, where visitors find ‘outstanding food’ and ‘welcoming, efficient service’.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • gastropub
  • disabled
  • wi-fi
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher
5
Thistleyhaugh Farm

Thistleyhaugh Farm

Longhorsley

‘Wonderful location in rural Northumberland. Friendly, peaceful; superb dinners and a lovely breakfast.’
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • fishing
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • activities
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
6
Dolffanog Fawr

Dolffanog Fawr

Tywyn

With Tal-y-llyn lake practically in the back garden, Cadair Idris behind, and ‘some of the finest walks in any national park’, Alex Yorke and Lorraine Hinkins’s Snowdonia B&B wins praise again this year.
  • golf
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • fishing
  • dog_friendly
  • guesthouse
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • view
  • guest_house
  • wi-fi
7
No. 33

No. 33

Hunstanton

On a quiet residential street a stroll from the sea in a Victorian resort town, Jeanne Whittome’s boutique B&B impressed readers with its ‘bold, contemporary style’.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • dog_friendly
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • seaside
  • b&b
  • disabled
  • golf
  • wi-fi
8
Killiane Castle Country House and Farm

Killiane Castle Country House and Farm

Drinagh

‘A beautiful place with great hosts.’ Guide readers ‘highly recommend’ this well-located former Norman castle-turned-farmhouse-turned-country guest house in Ireland’s Ancient East.
  • child_friendly
  • wi-fi
  • country_house
  • b&b
  • garden
  • historic
9
The Old Rectory at Stewton

The Old Rectory at Stewton

Louth

Guests in 2018 praise the ‘outstanding hospitality and attention to detail at this gem of a B&B’.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • dog_friendly
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
10
Trereife

Trereife

Penzance

An Elizabethan farmhouse remodelled in the reign of Queen Anne, 'Treeve' has been home to the Le Grice family since 1796.
  • weddings
  • child_friendly
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • wi-fi
  • romantic
  • honeymoon
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher

2018 Editor's Choice Value Hotels

Editor’s Choice Value Hotels

1
Special offer
Lake Isle

Lake Isle - D,B&B Third Night Free Special Offer

Uppingham

The food is the main course at Janine and Richard Burton’s restaurant-with-rooms. ‘How I wish we had a restaurant anywhere near as good as this where I live now,’ writes a regular reader this year, after returning to her old Rutland haunt.
  • child_friendly
  • value
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • gourmet
  • dog_friendly
  • wi-fi
2
Frog Street Farmhouse

Frog Street Farmhouse

Hatch Beauchamp

‘Such a peaceful, quiet place to stay. The log fire was lit ready for our arrival.’ A new endorsement this year for ‘perfect hosts’ David and Louise Farrance’s wisteria-festooned B&B.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • b&b
  • bird_watching
  • wi-fi
10% discount voucher
3
Cnapan

Cnapan

Newport

Friendly and welcoming as ever, this B&B is run by second-generation owners Michael and Judith Cooper, and their son, Oliver.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • wi-fi
4
The Ceilidh Place

The Ceilidh Place

Ullapool

There’s ‘a good night’s sleep’ and more at Jean Urquhart’s ‘lively’ Ceilidh Place – a popular fusion of cultural hub, bookshop and small hotel, one street back from the ferry terminal.
  • weddings
  • child_friendly
  • garden
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • value
  • wi-fi
25% voucher
5
The Black Swan

The Black Swan

Ravenstonedale

A babbling brook etches a course past Louise Dinnes’s ‘good-value, thoroughly dependable’ Victorian pub-with-rooms, where visitors find ‘outstanding food’ and ‘welcoming, efficient service’.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • gastropub
  • disabled
  • wi-fi
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher
6
Thistleyhaugh Farm

Thistleyhaugh Farm

Longhorsley

‘Wonderful location in rural Northumberland. Friendly, peaceful; superb dinners and a lovely breakfast.’
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • fishing
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • activities
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
7
Trelaske Hotel & Restaurant

Trelaske Hotel & Restaurant

Looe

Hazel Billington and Ross Lewin are the ‘excellent hosts’ of this ‘absolutely fantastic hotel’ that has guests returning year after year. ‘The standard remains high every time we visit.’
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • parking
  • wi-fi
10% discount voucher 25% voucher
8
Dalshian House

Dalshian House

Pitlochry

Martin and Heather Walls’s white-painted Georgian guest house feels ‘blissfully remote’ – robins and red squirrels in the ‘peaceful’ surrounding woodland are your only neighbours – but it is within easy distance of bustling Pitlochry.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • fishing
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
  • walking
  • parking
10% discount voucher 25% voucher
9
The Nag’s Head

The Nag’s Head

Pickhill

Janet and Edward Boynton’s 19th-century coaching inn between moors and dales is roundly endorsed by Guide readers, who praise its ‘hospitable, interesting owners’, ‘enjoyable dinners’, ‘relaxing atmosphere’ and ‘excellent value’.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • value
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • gastropub
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher
10
Inch House

Inch House

Thurles

‘Warm and charming in its small-scale grandeur’, the Egan family’s Georgian mansion sits amid a cereals farm in Tipperary countryside.
  • weddings
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
10% discount voucher Upgrade voucher

2017 Editors Choice Value

Editor’s Choice Value Hotels

1
Cnapan

Cnapan

Newport

Friendly and welcoming as ever, this B&B is run by second-generation owners Michael and Judith Cooper, and their son, Oliver.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • wi-fi
2
The Carpenter’s Arms

The Carpenter’s Arms

Stanton Wick

A row of former miners’ pantiled cottages combines into a rambling, ‘appealing’ country inn in a picturesque setting where, regulars report, ‘generous portions’ and ‘generous hospitality’ come as standard.
  • child_friendly
  • wifi
  • parking
  • gastropub
  • walking
  • wi-fi
3
The Old Rectory

The Old Rectory

Boscastle

‘What a super place to stay for tackling some of the Coastal Path; it ticks all possible boxes,’ writes a Guide inspector in 2018 of Sally and Chris Searle’s historic B&B.
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • value
  • dog_friendly
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • romantic
  • historic
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
4
Sea Mist House

Sea Mist House

Clifden

A knock at the cherry-red door to this ‘characterful’ B&B is answered by ‘warm, inherently hospitable’ Sheila Griffin.
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
5
The Manor Coach House

The Manor Coach House

Worcester

In ‘a lovely rural location’ yet within easy reach of the town centre and Worcester cathedral, Chrissie Mitchell's ‘spotless' and 'very reasonable' B&B is ‘surrounded by delight’.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • wi-fi
6
Grasshoppers

Grasshoppers

Glasgow

If you’re looking for a modestly priced hotel at the heart of the city, this is just the ticket – a modern B&B on the penthouse floor of a handsome, buff stone, 1900s office building, right by Central Station.
  • child_friendly
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • view
  • wi-fi
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher
7
Newbegin House

Newbegin House

Beverley

‘Perfect hosts’ Nuala and Walter Sweeney clearly enjoy welcoming guests to their ‘beautiful Georgian house’ in a market town dominated by its sublime Gothic minster.
  • b&b
  • garden
  • wi-fi
8
Eight Clarendon Crescent

Eight Clarendon Crescent

Leamington Spa

‘Lively hosts’ Christine and David Lawson ‘delight in sharing their space’, a ‘peaceful’ Regency villa near the town centre.
  • child_friendly
  • garden
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • b&b
9
Bealach House

Bealach House

Duror

Along a rough track ‘with not a sign of habitation’, Jim and Hilary McFadyen have posted encouraging notices (‘You’re on the right road!’) to arriving guests. ‘You wonder if there’s anything at the end; what you find is a lovely white house in a very pretty garden,’ say Guide inspectors in 2016.
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • guesthouse
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • guest_house
10
The Silverton

The Silverton

Shrewsbury

Just over the Welsh Bridge from the historic town centre, David Cheshire and Donna Miles’s ‘excellent-value’ restaurant-with-rooms is liked for its ‘great, friendly service’ and ‘modern, almost minimalist’ rooms.
  • child_friendly
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • disabled

2016 Editor's Choice Value Hotels

Editor’s Choice Value Hotels

1
Special offer
Castleman

Castleman - Midweek Special Offer

Blandford Forum

‘Set in a period property, this hotel pampers its clients like friends, and captures an age of country house hospitality,’ write readers this year, of Barbara Garnsworthy’s former dower house in a feudal village.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • garden
  • fishing
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • wi-fi
  • golf
25% voucher Upgrade voucher
2
The Nobody Inn

The Nobody Inn

Exeter

A ‘time capsule of ancient England’, Sue Burdge’s venerable former dwelling house has been the village pub and hub since 1837.
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • wifi
  • parking
  • gastropub
  • wi-fi
3
The Black Swan

The Black Swan

Ravenstonedale

A babbling brook etches a course past Louise Dinnes’s ‘good-value, thoroughly dependable’ Victorian pub-with-rooms, where visitors find ‘outstanding food’ and ‘welcoming, efficient service’.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • dog_friendly
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • gastropub
  • disabled
  • wi-fi
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher
4
The Old Store

The Old Store

Halnaker

Behind a ‘gorgeous, checkerboard red-brick-and-stone facade’, in a hamlet a mile from Goodwood and ‘an easy, breezy drive from Chichester’, the former village grocer’s shop is run as a friendly B&B.
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
5
Thistleyhaugh Farm

Thistleyhaugh Farm

Longhorsley

‘Wonderful location in rural Northumberland. Friendly, peaceful; superb dinners and a lovely breakfast.’
  • child_friendly
  • golf
  • walking
  • garden
  • value
  • fishing
  • bandb
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • activities
  • b&b
  • wi-fi
6
Ael y Bryn

Ael y Bryn

Eglwyswrw

‘Ten gold stars’ glitter among a constellation of guests’ praise for the ‘wonderful’ B&B with its ‘aura of tranquillity’ and views over the Preseli hills.
  • walking
  • bird_watching
  • garden
  • bandb
  • guesthouse
  • wifi
  • exceptional_value
  • view
  • b&b
  • guest_house
  • wi-fi
25% voucher
7
The Nag’s Head

The Nag’s Head

Pickhill

Janet and Edward Boynton’s 19th-century coaching inn between moors and dales is roundly endorsed by Guide readers, who praise its ‘hospitable, interesting owners’, ‘enjoyable dinners’, ‘relaxing atmosphere’ and ‘excellent value’.
  • child_friendly
  • walking
  • value
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • gastropub
10% discount voucher 25% voucher Upgrade voucher
8
The Abbey House

The Abbey House

Abbotsbury

In a ‘glorious position’ on the fringes of a historic coastal Dorset village, this traditional B&B has long been run by the ‘most welcoming’ Jonathan and Maureen Cooke.
  • weddings
  • garden
  • value
  • bandb
  • guesthouse
  • wifi
  • parking
  • exceptional_value
  • b&b
  • guest_house